University of Minnesota banner image Gold University of Minnesota M. Skip to main content. One Stop Directories Search U of M
Forest Resources Extension Banner Image

In This Section

   
 

Nicollet Island Planting Research Data

Mortality Rate: Mortality rate was calculated as an overall percentage and then broken down into mortality rate of trees that were adjusted, versus non-adjusted trees. Adjusted trees were those that were found buried too deeply in the containers when the trees were purchased. The excess soil and roots that were above the first main-order roots for these trees were subsequently removed prior to the beginning of the study. The range of excess soil that had to be removed was from 4-9 inches.
Overall, the mortality rate for the 97 adjusted trees was 13/97= 13%
The mortality rate for the 89 non-adjusted trees was 24/89=27%
Total trees in the study =186.

Growth rate: Growth rate was determined as a percentage increases in stem caliper (stem diameter measured at 6-12 inches above ground).

Condition Ratings: Separate condition rating for the stem and canopy were determined annually for each tree. Ratings were based on a four point system with 0 representing dead and 4 representing no "flaws" for the species. Stem condition ratings were based on wholeness and health of the stem tissue, with points subtracted for bark loss and/or cambial death...for any reason. Canopy condition rating were based on the characteristic of the species, specifically live crown ration, density, balance (symmetry), as well as dieback. Leaf size and color was not taken into consideration.

Acer nigrum "Green Column"
Mortality rate                                            46%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                   50%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees            40%
Growth rate                                               54%
Condition ratings:
            Stem Ratings 3.5+                        4/7
            Stem Ratings <1.5                        2/7
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                      6/7
            Canopy Rating <1.5                      1/7

Acer rubrum x saccharinum “Autumn Blaze”
Mortality rate                                            17%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                   11%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees            33%
Growth rate                                             116%
Condition ratings:
Stem Ratings 3.5+                                  10/10
            Stem Ratings <1.5                       0/10
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                     9/10
            Canopy Rating <1.5                     0/10

Acer saccharum “Fall Fiesta”
Mortality rate                                            62%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                  20%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees           88%
Growth rate                                              89%
Condition ratings:
Stem Ratings 3.5+                                    3/5
            Stem Ratings <1.5                        0/5
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                      4/5
            Canopy Rating <1.5                      1/5

Celtis occidentalis
Mortality rate                                              8%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                   11%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees              0%
Growth rate                                             102%
Condition ratings:
            Stem Ratings 3.5+                       11/11
            Stem Ratings <1.5                         0/11
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                     10/11
            Canopy Rating <1.5                       0/11

Fraxinus americana "Autumn Blaze"
Mortality rate                                              8%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                     0%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees            14%
Growth rate                                               89%
Condition ratings:
            Stem Ratings 3.5+                       10/11
            Stem Ratings <1.5                         0/11
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                     10/11
            Canopy Rating <1.5                       0/11

 

Fraxinus americana "Autumn Purple"
Mortality rate                                             0%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                    0%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees             0%
Growth rate                                            126%
Condition ratings:
            Stem Ratings 3.5+                       12/12
            Stem Ratings <1.5                        0/12
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                    12/12
            Canopy Rating <1.5                     0/12

 

Fraxinus nigra "Fall Gold"
Mortality rate                                              17%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                     8%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees              8%
Growth rate                                                95%
Condition ratings:
            Stem Ratings 3.5+                       10/12
            Stem Ratings <1.5                        0/12
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                     6/12
            Canopy Rating <1.5                     0/12

 

Fraxinus nigra x mandshurica "Northern Gem"
Mortality rate                                         0%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees               0%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees        0%
Growth rate                                           99%
Condition ratings:
            Stem Ratings 3.5+                        9/12
            Stem Ratings <1.5                        1/12
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                     6/12
            Canopy Rating <1.5                     1/12

 

Fraxinus nigra x mandshurica "Northern Treasure"
Mortality rate                                          8%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                  0%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees         20%
Growth rate                                            100%
Condition ratings:
          Stem Ratings 3.5+                       12/12
            Stem Ratings <1.5                       0/12
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                   10/12
            Canopy Rating <1.5                     0/12

 

 Gymnocladus dioicus
Mortality rate                                          31%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                 40%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees          25%
Growth rate                                           75%
Condition ratings:
             Stem Ratings 3.5+                       9/9
            Stem Ratings <1.5                        0/9
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                     5/9
            Canopy Rating <1.5                     0/9

 

Maackia amurensis
Mortality rate                                          17%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                 20%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees          14%
Growth rate                                           63%
Condition ratings:
             Stem Ratings 3.5+                       8/8
            Stem Ratings <1.5                        0/8
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                     7/8
            Canopy Rating <1.5                     0/8

Quercus macrocarpa x robur "Heritage"
Mortality rate                                         42%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                0%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees         56%
Growth rate                                           71%
Condition ratings:
             Stem Ratings 3.5+                      5/7
            Stem Ratings <1.5                       1/7
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                     2/7
            Canopy Rating <1.5                     1/7

Tilia americana "Boulevard"
Mortality rate                                         31%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                14%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees         50%
Growth rate                                           57%
Condition ratings:
             Stem Ratings 3.5+                      4/9
            Stem Ratings <1.5                       1/9
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                     8/9
            Canopy Rating <1.5                     0/9

 

 Quercus macrocarpa
Mortality rate                                         15%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                25%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees         11%
Growth rate                                           49%
Condition ratings:
             Stem Ratings 3.5+                       10/10
            Stem Ratings <1.5                        0/10
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                     6/10
            Canopy Rating <1.5                     0/10

Ulmus "Triumph"
Mortality rate                                          0%
Mortality rate, adjusted trees                  0%
Mortality rate, non-adjusted trees           0%
Growth rate                                          249%
Condition ratings:
             Stem Ratings 3.5+                      12/12
            Stem Ratings <1.5                       0/12
            Canopy Rating 3.5+                    12/12
            Canopy Rating <1.5                     0/12

 

 

 

 

 

 


© 2006 by the Regents of the University of Minnesota. All rights reserved. Privacy Statement.
The University of Minnesota Extension is an equal opportunity educator and employer.
Revised: 10/06/2008 Liam McClannahan, Stephen Schott, and Adam Flett at treeinfo@umn.edu.
.